General Discussion:

Square Foot Gardening


Messages posted to thread:

From:Date:Zone:
Diane Ziomek16-Feb-04 03:16 PM EST 2b   
doris07-Mar-04 09:54 AM EST 3   
Diane Ziomek08-Jul-04 03:45 PM EST 2b   
Karen19-Apr-05 11:13 AM EST 6a   


Subject: Square Foot Gardening
From: Diane Ziomek
Zone: 2b
Date: 16-Feb-04 03:16 PM EST

Has anyone tried Mel Bartholemew's Square Foot Gardening Method? I have a small garden space, and am very interested to find out if it works as well as his book says it does. I would appreciate any input, help or advice. Thank you in advance.


Subject: RE: Square Foot Gardening
From: doris
Zone: 3
Date: 07-Mar-04 09:54 AM EST

Hi, Diane. I have that book, too. I haven't tried the method myself, yet (I've got a small garden, and I'm currently too enamoured of flowering plants to start growing veggies). However, a friend of mine followed the advice in the book with great results. She was able to grow lots of varieties in a confined space; it looked good, too. If and when I'm ready to give up some of my perennials, that's the method I'll be using (unless I just plant vegetables among the perennials--that method also works, especially with the more ornamental edibles.) Hope this helps. Good luck with your garden.


Subject: RE: Square Foot Gardening
From: Diane Ziomek
Zone: 2b
Date: 08-Jul-04 03:45 PM EST

Just a note for any of you who are curious about this method - I've plnated most of my garden this way, and so far it seems to be working ok. I do have 2 rows of peas, and a hothouse with tomatoes & peppers, but the rest of my garden is based on the square foot method. I must say I didn't measure out an exact grid...I eyeballed it for the most part, but it still seems to be working ok. I did find out one thing, though...do not plant more than the reccommended amounts for certain veggies, because they will require more thinning. I found this out the hard way....I planted 81 radishes, turnips & lettuce seeds, and am now thinning them out to make room for them to grow to a good size. Oh well, hindsight is 20/20. Have fun gardening!


Subject: RE: Square Foot Gardening
From: Karen
Zone: 6a
Date: 19-Apr-05 11:13 AM EST

I tried something similar to this last year with great results. Instead of using a string grid, I laid 12x12 patio stones in a checkboard pattern and planted in the square foot spaces between them. I had checked out some pictures of Bartholomew's method in action and thought it looked a little messy, not to mention difficult to reach the stuff in the middle. (I have a bad back, so bending at the waist is difficult.) My layout allowed me to walk between my plantings and looked very attractive. When a sqaure was done, I either replanted it with something else or plunked a potted plant or ornament in it. The best part was that I only needed to weed my veggie patch TWICE all summer long. The down side was that the stones seemed to encourage slugs, which were already a problem because we had such a wet summer. I intend to to use the copper mesh from Lee Valley this year, so hopefully that will help.


In order to post the forum, you must register to the site.
To register, click here.

If you have already registered, you must log in.
  • New Eden
  • Kids Garden
  • Plant a Row Grow a Row